Elliott played at Neil House in Columbus, OH on 3-6-96. This was part of the tour he was on with The Softies. I've seen it listed as Neal House or The Neil House (with the word "the" in front) but the flyer just says Neil House.

Setlist:

No Confidence Man
Needle in the Hay
Angeles
Coming Up Roses
Punch and Judy
Condor Ave.
Last Call
The Biggest Lie
Thirteen

The flyer below was from  @eightdouble on twitter at whose living room this show took place.
Below is a link to an audio recording of the show on bandcamp:

elliottsmithshows.bandcamp.com/album/elliott-smith-at-neil-house-in-columbus-oh-3-6-96

​Below is a YouTube video of just the audio. I believe it's the same audio as the bandcamp one above.