Elliott played at CBGB's Gallery in New York, NY in August 1995. Before the recording of the show appeared, this show was often listed as being from July.  However, the person who actually recorded the show, Josh Gaffin, said that it was from August so I'm going with August and also assuming there was only one show at this venue (although Elliott did play a handful of east coast shows in July but none in August so, who knows, it could be from July, let me know if you know more). The recording was given to me by Kii Komori/antifakitten on Instagram and they had gotten it from Josh, thanks to them.

Setlist:

Clementine
Coming Up Roses
The White Lady Loves You More
Alphabet Town
Roman Candle
See You Later
Christian Brothers
Condor Ave
Southern Belle

An audio recording that is free to stream and download is here.